New York · est. 2013Saturday, September 5, 2026
Inside Immigration

Plain-language guides to US immigration, asylum and USCIS procedure.

Formularios · Humanitarian

Defensive asylum in immigration court

Asylum raised as a defence to removal before an immigration judge. It arises when someone is placed in proceedings, when USCIS refers an affirmative case, or when a person passes a credible fear interview after expedited removal. The judge, not an asylum officer, decides it, and DHS appears as the opposing party.

Tiempo habitual: Immigration court cases commonly run two to four years from the notice to appear to a merits decision, longer with an appeal. EOIR does not publish a national median for asylum cases.Tarifas: $100 at filing, $102 a year while pending, $1,030 for a BIA appeal (waivable), plus work permit fees. No fee waiver is possible for either Public Law 119-21 asylum fee.

Leer esta página en inglés

Para quién es. Anyone in removal proceedings before an immigration judge who fears persecution or torture in their home country.

Los formularios, en orden

6 formularios
EOIR-28EOIR-33/ICI-589I-765EOIR-26EOIR-26A
  1. 1

    Get a lawyer on the record and file the change of address form

    EOIR-28EOIR-33/IC

    Quién
    The respondent and their representative
    Cuándo
    Immediately after the notice to appear
    Tarifa
    $0

    An address that is out of date is how most in absentia removal orders happen.

  2. 2

    Attend the master calendar hearing and plead to the notice to appear

    Quién
    The respondent
    Cuándo
    Usually within weeks or months of the notice to appear
    Tarifa
    $0

    The judge sets a deadline to file the asylum application at this hearing.

  3. 3

    File Form I-589 with the immigration court

    I-589

    Quién
    The respondent
    Cuándo
    By the judge's deadline, and within one year of the last arrival unless an exception applies
    Tarifa
    $100 Public Law 119-21 asylum application fee, paid through the EOIR Payment Portal

    Filing with the wrong court gets the application rejected. EOIR fees must be paid electronically since February 23, 2026.

  4. 4

    Provide biometrics and biographic information to USCIS

    Quién
    The respondent
    Cuándo
    As instructed after filing
    Tarifa
    $0

    EOIR filings still need DHS background checks; the instructions for submitting them are on the USCIS immigration benefits in EOIR proceedings page.

  5. 5

    Apply for a work permit once the 180-day clock allows

    I-765

    Quién
    The respondent
    Cuándo
    Apply after 150 days of a pending application
    Tarifa
    $520 paper or $470 online plus any Public Law 119-21 fee

    The clock stops for any continuance the respondent requests.

  6. 6

    Attend the individual merits hearing

    Quién
    The respondent, with witnesses and evidence
    Cuándo
    Often a year or more after the master calendar hearing
    Tarifa
    $0

    This is the trial. DHS counsel cross-examines and the judge rules, sometimes orally from the bench.

  7. 7

    Appeal an adverse decision to the Board of Immigration Appeals

    EOIR-26EOIR-26A

    Quién
    The respondent
    Cuándo
    Within 30 days of the judge's decision
    Tarifa
    $1,030, waivable on Form EOIR-26A

    The 30-day deadline is unforgiving and mailing time does not extend it.

  8. 8

    Pay the Annual Asylum Fee while the case remains pending

    Quién
    The principal applicant
    Cuándo
    As ordered in writing by the judge or the Board
    Tarifa
    $102 per year

    Paid through the EOIR Payment Portal under the Annual Asylum Fee filing type.

Dónde suele fallar

  • Not updating Form EOIR-33/IC after a move is the leading cause of in absentia removal orders.
  • USCIS address changes do not reach the immigration court; both agencies need telling separately.
  • Requesting continuances stops the work permit clock, so representation delays can cost a year of work authorisation.
  • Filing the I-589 with USCIS when you are in EOIR proceedings gets it rejected and can waste the one-year deadline.
  • EOIR no longer accepts checks or money orders, so a filer without a card or bank account has a real problem.

Qué cambió en 2025 y 2026

  • From February 23, 2026 all EOIR immigration fees must be paid through the EOIR Payment Portal; checks and money orders are refused.
  • The Public Law 119-21 $100 asylum application fee and $102 Annual Asylum Fee apply in immigration court as well as at USCIS.
  • EOIR has consolidated and relocated courts repeatedly since 2025; confirm the filing address on the Find an Immigration Court page before mailing anything.
  • Case completion quotas and reassignments have shortened continuance practice in many courts.

Trámites relacionados

Fuentes: justice.gov · justice.gov · justice.gov · uscis.gov · uscis.gov · uscis.gov